Phil Simms: "No, Eli Is Not One Of The Elites....."

[Morehead State]

Thats a long way from 30 or 50.... and even some of the names on your list are highly debatable.

He asked for 10.
You can debate as to weather some of these guys are top 10, but there's no debate that they were better than Eli.
Some of you guys and your Eli worship. Its just silliness.

I suppose we should just let you guys have your fantasy and be done with you. I guess I need to show more restraint. Its like telling kids there's no Santa Claus.

[Morehead State]

shameless bump because I think its funny....

You're a good poster but it wasn't really that funny.
But as long as you think so........that's what's important.

[rebelfan1966]

He asked for 10.
You can debate as to weather some of these guys are top 10, but there's no debate that they were better than Eli.
Some of you guys and your Eli worship. Its just silliness.

I suppose we should just let you guys have your fantasy and be done with you. I guess I need to show more restraint. Its like telling kids there's no Santa Claus.

I was responding to your assertion that 30 and probably even 50 were better than Eli.....

[Imgrate]

Really? If picking of QBs playing today, name 10 that are better than Eli?

There aren't ten now, but before last year there were a bunch. He could easily be placed anywhere from 5 to 10th after 2010 and the same could be said about him for every year before that. Thus, me saying the majority of his career

[Morehead State]

I was responding to your assertion that 30 and probably even 50 were better than Eli.....

I feel badly..........To all my Eli Cultist friends.......

Santa Claus is real!!!!!!

[rebelfan1966]

There aren't ten now, but before last year there were a bunch. He could easily be placed anywhere from 5 to 10th after 2010 and the same could be said about him for every year before that. Thus, me saying the majority of his career

"Thus" .... now there's a word that does not get used very much : )

[GameTime]

You're a good poster but it wasn't really that funny.
But as long as you think so........that's what's important.

oh come on.....if this isnt a soap opera of QB discussion then I dont what it is.....
You guys are knowledgable and all but its funny to see how the back and forth goes to try to convince one another on who is right or who's points are more valid. Not only now but 20 years from now or for that matter 30 years ago...

[Imgrate]

Until it is a foregone conclusion that Eli is a HoF qb (And no it is not a 100% guaranteed thing yet for him like it is for Brady or Peyton) then I cannot rank Eli as being better than any qb in the hall.

[rebelfan1966]

I feel badly..........To all my Eli Cultist friends.......

Santa Claus is real!!!!!!

Well, to be technical, there really was a St. Nicholas..... just saying

[GameTime]

I feel badly..........To all my Eli Cultist friends.......

Santa Claus is real!!!!!!

Santa is Elite for sure.....