Do kickers and punters belong in the Hall of Fame?

[penguinfarmer]

My only thought is how ironic that this thread was created by HallOfFame. One would think he was the only one qualified to answer said question...

Even for those who actually vote, it's never that black and white. It's a valid question.

[keyofgmen]

The fact that Ray Guy is not in HOF is a crime.

[Hall of Fame]

I think anyone who plays should be considered. If a kick returner plays better than all other kick returners, why not?

"Devin Hester you are ridiculous"

[Hall of Fame]

Even for those who actually vote, it's never that black and white. It's a valid question.

You sig copycat! haha jk

[GameTime]

if you are one of the best at what you do then why not.....

[Chris Christie]

They definitely deserve a spot in the hall of fame, they put teams in positions to win games. Whether its pinning an offense deep up against their own end zone, or scoring that game winning or game tying last second field goal.

[Captain Chaos]

It would be a shame if they didn't....

[Roosevelt]

They are players too, don't see why not.

It's simple. Because they are kickers and punters.

[Rudyy]

It's simple. Because they are kickers and punters.

Makes sense

[Diamondring]

Yes cause what if they can tackle and cover on special teams as well? Kickers could do more than just kick the ball.