Can we all agree now that letting Mario Manningham go was Dumb Dunb Dumb

[BlueSanta]

Actually the title of the thread is "Can we all now agree that letting MM go was Dumb Dunb. Dumb. It think thats self explanatory.

hehe

[SiddFinch1]

In these days of the cap..can't work

[TroyArcher]

He has 5 more catches than Hixon and 50 less yards. They both have one TD. I do not agree.

[ryan12]

omg who cares we dont have him anymore. my head is spining from this thread

[Morehead State]

Thats the thing MS, folks just want to look at stats as well as percentages and not what is often called the "intangibles." Mario Manningham stretched defenses and forced them to account for him freeing up others. MM was great for offense even when he didn't catch the ball. No matter how we look at it, our offense is not performing the same as it did with MM on the field. Lets hope that we fix what is wrong and make a strong run after this bye week.

It is kind of like when folks just take in to account the guy that gets the sack but not the other guy that pressured the QB to run that way.

"Intangibles" are things like making clutch catches in big spots in big games. Like turning short gains into huge plays. Lets look at the comparison in that context between Hixon and Manningham.
Well with Hixon there is no record of that at all. With Manningham there is an extensive list.

[Morehead State]

omg who cares we dont have him anymore. my head is spining from this thread

We're having a classic sports argument. What's your problem?

Its a football message board. How dare we argue about football!!!!

[jakegibbs]

Just watching him come back to that first pass made me feel awful

You don't break up a SB winning team or you didn't back in the dynasty days anyway. An Eli took a pay cut to keep him to boot right? Didn't they restructure Eli's contract for salary cap space to try & keep players like Manningham?

Yep yep yep I agree it was dumb dumb & dumber

[jakegibbs]

"Intangibles" are things like making clutch catches in big spots in big games. Like turning short gains into huge plays. Lets look at the comparison in that context between Hixon and Manningham.
Well with Hixon there is no record of that at all. With Manningham there is an extensive list.

+1 Hixon has a record but it's not a good record to have injury after injury which I know could happen to Manningham but a record is what it is a record of past history.

[ryan12]

We're having a classic sports argument. What's your problem?

Its a football message board. How dare we argue about football!!!!

go to general sports then because a 17 pages on thread debating a player who isn't on our team doesnt belong in TAGF... haha btw are you Moreheads Underdogs in the giants message board fantasy football?

[Morehead State]

go to general sports then because a 17 pages on thread debating a player who isn't on our team doesnt belong in TAGF... haha btw are you Moreheads Underdogs in the giants message board fantasy football?

Hah...yes I am. Who are you?