You won't know what your players can do until you test them. I'm sure some of those tests came on game day.
We must not discount the 2 SB's he has participated in. As well as his contribution to Eli's development.
There are many, many OC's out there who would love to have the resume of Kevin Gilbride.
Even the gripes about KG make no sense.
Is he unimaginative and predictable, or is he drawing up off the wall plays when simplicity is whats called for. And dont tell me he is doing both at the wrong time, save yourselves from looking even worse in this debate.