GILBRIDE COST US THE GAME

[RoanokeFan]

Even the gripes about KG make no sense.

Is he unimaginative and predictable, or is he drawing up off the wall plays when simplicity is whats called for. And dont tell me he is doing both at the wrong time, save yourselves from looking even worse in this debate.

That's not possible lol

[Razur]

Gilbride is just setting up his resume for another HC job somewhere. We don't have to agree with this statement, as it was intended for a GM or owner looking for a new HC to hire. We should be more concerned about if he leaves, who we wind up with.

[BuffyBlueII]

Well if KG is the best OC because he has 2 Rings, does that mean tha. BJ is the best RB?

[BigBlue wins]

Well if KG is the best OC because he has 2 Rings, does that mean tha. BJ is the best RB?

No, but he has the best initials

[rcrane]

Sometimes when a play is so predictable.. its not predictable. Ever play rocks paper scissors?

[BrianK01]

We must not discount the 2 SB's he has participated in. As well as his contribution to Eli's development.

There are many, many OC's out there who would love to have the resume of Kevin Gilbride.

Well said

[TrueBlue@NYC]

He's certainly good but there's a few guys I'd rank over him. Sean Payton, Josh McDaniels (crappy HC, awesome OC) Mike McCoy from Denver (anyone who gets to the playoffs with Tebow as a starting QB gets huge props lol), Maybe Chip Kelly too...These are just my personal preferences.

Except Sean Payton isn't an OC, he's a Head Coach and Josh McDaniels hasn't had as much sustained success as KG.

Mike McCoy in DEN has been brilliant the past two seasons.

[ELI_HOF_NYG]

Very easily because it is true.

can you back that with stats or some info that supports your claim? because he will back his with 8 playoff wins and 2 super bowl rings.

[BuffyBlueII]

can you back that with stats or some info that supports your claim? because he will back his with 8 playoff wins and 2 super bowl rings.

According to your argument, Brandon Jacobs is h best RB because he has 2 Rings. Our offense is one of the most predictable in NFL. We win in spite of KG. The guy is a horrible coach and coordinator. No surprise that when KG stopped being the QB coach and took the OC job that Eli Manning became a better QB.

[Drez]

According to your argument, Brandon Jacobs is h best RB because he has 2 Rings. Our offense is one of the most predictable in NFL. We win in spite of KG. The guy is a horrible coach and coordinator. No surprise that when KG stopped being the QB coach and took the OC job that Eli Manning became a better QB.

Yet, we've had a top 10 offense every year since he's been the OC. Strange.