[quote user="MattMeyerBud"][quote user="dezzzR"][quote user="JPizzack"][quote user="MattMeyerBud"][quote user="Morehead State"][quote user="JPizzack"]
[quote user="MattMeyerBud"]but I am saying the whole "MOOREHEAD WATCHED THE GAMES AND THATS HOW HE KNOWS" argument has really taken a beating with your most recent stances on Eli
yea....i realized that with last winter's Larry Bird debate. lol</P>
Show me where I have said anything like that in this debate.</P>
Until then, you have no leg to stand on.</P>
well actually isn't that EXACTLY what you are doing though? You just tried to say stats had no bearing on it...
Its all based on what you watch out of Simms and Eli. You say Simms lack of stats don't tell the story and Eli's awesome stats don't tell the story....
I dont really feel the need to justify continuing this debate really, i mean I GUESS i know where he's coming from sometimes, because like last winter's debate, i know NOBODY is nearly as good as michael jordan, and likely ppl will only come close....
But it's not like we're discussing "<U>greatest quarterbacks ever"</U> cuz Simms isnt near that list obviously.</P>
[/quote]were arguing greatest giants qb ever.
ill throw monkey wrench in here. what about tittle?
two things make Title not even allowed in the convo:
1) I just can't bring Leatherheads into the convo. It was a COMPLETE different game then
2) He was only a Giant for 4 years
I feel like Manning and Simms are the only 2 qualified people in the debate due to the tenure at their position, and on this team.
Simms right now, yes....but considering Eli has plenttttyyyy of years left in the tank, Simms will be a distant 2nd by the end of Eli's career.</P>