Matt said it best, you dont give up talent for potential.
1.There is no way that Indy would trade away their franchise for Eli. (so its a moot point)
2. Lets hope Eli's poor season last year isn't the start of his decline. Deal with it people....he ain't Peyton. And right now, he's probably not as good as Luck either.
"Phil Simms is the greatest QB in Giants history" ........Mahatma Gandhi