[quote user="Morehead State"][quote user="JPizzack"][quote user="Morehead State"]
OK..lets step back and look at this objectively. If someone was coming to this debate for the first time. Whichwould they say is the "obsessed" position?</p>
1. Eli is a good QB, even top 10, but doesn't protect the ball well enough.</p>
2. Eli is a future Hall of Famer and a gunslinger.</p>
honestly MH....I think people calling him a hall of famer is kind of a rarity....
gunslinger, sure...we have that debate in here, but 1 person doesnt make it acommon argument. lol</p>
Guys who got beat up in high school for lunch money, by definition can't be gunslingers.</p>
And Matt has repeatedly stated that he is a gunslinger who is headed for the Hall of Fame. All because he might put up Kerry Collins career numbers. Its nonsense. Its these extreem statements that I must challenge.</p>
You don't go to the Hall of Fame unless you are one of the top players at your position in your era.</p>[/quote]id just like to add phil simms is a borderline hall of famer and eli is on track to break pretty much all of his records if he hasnt already. soo...