[quote user="MattMeyerBud"][quote user="dezzzR"][quote user="JPizzack"]
[quote user="MattMeyerBud"]it would be really hard to justify Eli as a HOF QB then[/quote]</p>
not even on the same level, matt....
Eli in 07 played some of the cleanest football ever. It wasnt flashy or anything, but he was great.
This year, he just picked defenses apart.
Eli WON both Superbowls. He has both MVPs to prove it.
Roethlisberger has 2 rings and no SB MVP lol</p>[/quote]But there a lot of people (even Giants fans) that think Tuck should of won the MVP in 07. ****, I know people that think Tuck should of won it this year too (cough matt). However that is a good point about the no mvps for Ben.
tuck balled the **** out in the superbowl[/quote]He did. I think he deserved it in 07, I thought Eli earned it this year. He dragged this team by the ear all season long.