Luck is one of them but I can't say that he would end up any better than Keapernick, Wilson or RG.
Then there are the guys who are just coming into their own now or within the last year or 2, like Ryan and Flacco.
Then there are the guys who have been around and we've seen their best like Eli, Ben and Rivers.
Then there are the all time great 4 in Brady, Peyton, Brees and Rodgers.
Who would I take? It depends on for what. for now? For the next 3 years? For the next 10 years?
Thats an insult to the other 52 guys on the team. Eli is the QB...therefor an very important component to our championships. But he's ONE component.
Our defense was outstanding in those runs. I mean all time great at times. Eli was clutch and I am not taking that away from him.
His conribution in 2007 was far less than 2011. But he's an important part in both.