This is not about placing the right blame on Eli or placing the right blame on Peyton or any other QB.
AGAIN, YOU ARE NOT BEING ATTACKED.
It's about QB performance and team performance. One QB has played bad in several playoff performances, but it's because he didn't have a good team.
On the other hand, OUR QB's bad performance are on him...but there's no mention of the team....huh? And if you said "I NEVER SAID THAT" I'll quote the post for you.
But in the wins? "Our team AROUND him played great" These are contradicting statements here.
I already told you that wasn't the point of the thread.
But I can see you want to make it that because it's easier to counter, clearly you're having a hard time arguing with the points I made above, so you're straw manning it up.
"But Eli's losses are because of his performance".........
You didn't type these exact words, suggesting this is what I think?
"Phil Simms is the greatest QB in Giants history" ........Mahatma Gandhi
Drez is obsessed with me. Ever since he ratted me out on this thread. He believes I "forced" him to whine to the mods. He also (like you) has no friggin idea of what I think about Eli or most any other topic.
Get over yourself.
Also, you said earlie that Ruddy can speak for herself. If that's the case, isn't she capable of forming her own opinions?
And finally I was having an actual intelligent and respectful discussion with a good poster about Peyton Manning and you chime in along with Mr Happy and wreck the entire thing.
Delicreep left and then all hell broke loose with 420. Which, despite another of your mischaracterizations, I had no involvement with.
Go get drunk in The Big Easy........It should clear your head.
By making a jab, you mean I clarified that Ruddy didn't say anything about wins or losses.