For those that believe Gilbride is a really good coach please ask yourself 1 question

[Redeyejedi]

That's the thing. If we did get a new OC Eli would have full reign to call the offense however he pleases.

And we would THRIVE.

LOL wow u should stop right now

[Marvelousmik]

Oops forgot Rodgers.. Matt Ryan LOL please don't make me laugh.

Guy has the most unbelievable receiving corps in the league (not to mention which is probably the biggest reason for his success), Tony Gonzalez.

Brees turns the ball over just as much if not more than Eli and he has a "safe" "high percentage" offense.

matt ryan has the most weapons, but i still think he is a very smart qb. just watch him play . brees doesnt turn the ball over more than eli. He turns it over a lot, but still less.

[Marvelousmik]

I took it as a general statement. However, Brees turns the ball over a lot.

Dont let that happen again.

Lol im just playing. its all good.

[Roosevelt]

All because Rosie asked if Eli would want a new OC, lol.

Oh yeah, it's always my fault. ;]

[Marvelousmik]

I don't know if I would say smarter, probably consistent is a better word.

i think those guys i mentioned make better decisions on the field. Eli makes great decisions and reads defenses well, but the guys i mentioned in my opinion make less mistakes. Another person who reads defenses very well, believe it or not is tony romo. However, he fits under the eli category in terms of decision making.

[NYG4lifeNYK]

So you are saying you would get rid of Gilbride despite Eli's wishes. Interesting.

I guess most people think of you as being more of a homer than me, so I find it interesting that you would just fire Gilbride, while I would defer to Eli. I believe Eli is that important to this franchise.

I believe they could convince Eli to lead this offense much like Peyton does in any offense he's in.

I have that much faith in Eli, has nothing to do with being a homer. Eli doesn't get enough credit. Never has. never will. Especially not with Gilbride's offense because it's not a sexy offense.

[TheEnigma]

Not all interceptions are because of bad decision making of the QB. A decent amount of them are bad throws whether overthrowing or undethrowing the target. Just something I think should be cleared up.

[gmen0820]

If you're just gonna make **** up without supporting it, why settle for Eli being the third smartest QB? Why not just make him number one?

[Marvelousmik]

Not all interceptions are because of bad decision making of the QB. A decent amount of them are bad throws whether overthrowing or undethrowing the target. Just something I think should be cleared up.

i took that into consideration. i also take the passes that shoud have been intercepted but wasnt into consideration as well.

[Drez]

matt ryan has the most weapons, but i still think he is a very smart qb. just watch him play . brees doesnt turn the ball over more than eli. He turns it over a lot, but still less.

Over the past 3 years Brees and Eli have thrown an equal number of interceptions (55).