Vick couldn't run this offense. It'd be a horrible fit. Plus he sucks.
I wouldn't pay Vince Young Carr money, he's worth less because he comes with baggage.
And I wouldn't bring Vick here if he was free...unless we're looking for a 4th string RB of course
Not to mention VY single handedly sabatoged the Eagles season with the whole "Dream Team" thing... the press would be baiting him to no end for idiotic sound bites....
For that alone... Nooooooooooooooooooo
Last few avatars: Nicks, Bradshaw, Jacobs - who's the next future ex-Giant
Vince Young would never be able to get a handle on this offense.
Vince young is a million times better than Carr. Who cares if he knows the playbook if he holds onto the ball longer than Kurt Warner. I would take him over Carr any day of the week.