No, he still needs to do more
Yes, he is more consistent
He will be considered just as good
Let's just hope the Falcons lose on Sunday so we won't have this debate
I dont care really. As long as Eli plays great for the Giants I couldn't care less where he is ranked....
Measure Twice......Cut Once"
Eli Manning has more super bowl wins then Matt Ryan has playoff victories.
Giants fan since the early 80s
Who gives a ****. Until we make the playoffs again with good quarterback play I don't wanna hear a damn thing about none of this elite bull.
lmfao you aren't serious right? I haven't even read all the responses to this, but the title just provoked me.....you're kidding right????
Russell Wilson, the rookie he's facing this weekend already has more playoff wins....go figure
Meh. The entire ELIte thing is because of the E-L-I. If we were to actually get technical about it, there are only 2-3 actual ELIte QBs in NFL and as of right now, Eli Manning is not one of them. They would be Aaron Rodgers, Peyton Manning and Tom Brady. Now, if we were writing about ELIte post season QBs, Eli Manning is in that discussion. Of course this can all chancge next year in regard to overall ELIteness.
I couldn’t care less if Matt Ryan or anyone else is ranked higher or lower than Eli Manning. All I am concerned with is Eli Manning stepping it up and getting This Team back on track next season.
Matt Ryan not winning a Ring this year. Tom Brady is not gonna be denied this time.
Last edited by BuffyBlueII; 01-09-2013 at 03:10 AM.
He's not winning again. His team can't beat a single one of the remaining NFC teams.