Well, if we don't make him an offer commensurate with his skills, even if you can't see them, then he'll be wearing a different uniform in 2013. Teams will offer him a lot of money to play for them. If you're suggesting Reese will get a second chance next year, you'd be wrong. Back to back 1,000+ yard seasons, leading receiver in both of those seasons, Pro Bowl invitation.
As for your passes dropped argument, Eli overthew/underthrew a lot of passes and made some terrible decisions. What do we do about that?
All receivers drop passes and with all the passes Cruz dropped, he still went over the 1,000 yard mark.
The players with the most dropped pass in 2012 were Jimmy Graham with 13, and Cruz, Brandon Marshall, Demariyus Thomas and Calvin Johnson with 10.
Bums, the lot of them.
Cruz did not have a top 5 wr season this year.. end of story.