What is the best giants team ever?

[Rudyy]

So a team that dominates all of football going 14-2 and winning the SB like 1986, is not as good as the team that went 9-7 and won the SB like 2011, solely because Eli is better than Simms?? Is that what you are saying??

Wow just wow!

Doesn't make any sense lol.

[nhpgiantsfan]

No sir the team with the best qb is the best team in history of the team if you won the sb.. i'd say the pats best years were with brady.. our best years with eli.. packers best years with rodgers.. colts best years with peyton.. broncos best years with elway (or maybe peyton now if they win sb) and ravens best years with flacco if they win the big one.. i can go on n on.

So a team that dominates all of football going 14-2 and winning the SB like 1986, is not as good as the team that went 9-7 and won the SB like 2011, solely because Eli is better than Simms?? Is that what you are saying??

Wow just wow!

[Giantsfan241]

Without a doubt.

[Giantsfan241]

The quarterback is not the team.

The QB makes the team.

[Roosevelt]

sigh you roosevelt Eli is the best simms doesn't have anything on eli, simms was v good but eli is elite.

Of course Phil has things on Eli, but that's for another thread.

[Giantsfan241]

Some things but eli > simms.

[Rudyy]

The QB makes the team.

He's an important piece, but he is not the team.

[Giantsfan241]

Lol okay... lol

[Roosevelt]

Some things but eli > simms.

That's cool that you feel that way. It's just not relevant to this thread.

[Giantsfan241]

You're the one making it about it, ur right let's not discuss this here some people will get v angry.