What is the best giants team ever?

[moosedrool]

Anyone who thinks the 2011 team was better than the 1986 team is probably age 37 years or younger. I can't see any Giant fan over the age of 10 in 1986 possibly saying 2011 was better than 1986. It's not even close.

17-2 record

49-3 division playoffs over SF
17-0 conference playoffs over WAS
39-20 super bowl over DEN

All three games the Giants dominated from the opening whistle to the end. They never had a chance.

[Roosevelt]

Anyone who thinks the 2011 team was better than the 1986 team is probably age 37 years or younger. I can't see any Giant fan over the age of 10 in 1986 possibly saying 2011 was better than 1986. It's not even close.

17-2 record

49-3 division playoffs over SF
17-0 conference playoffs over WAS
39-20 super bowl over DEN

All three games the Giants dominated from the opening whistle to the end. They never had a chance.

You're right. The '86 Giants we're a dominant team.

With our 2011 team, we knew they could beat any team on any given day, but we were anything but dominant.

[YATittle1962]

I have no idea why '07 and '11 are even mentioned in this conversation

they might be in the top 10 best Giant teams ever .....maybe

some of the best Giant teams ever unfortunately didn't win championships

[nhpgiantsfan]

I have no idea why '07 and '11 are even mentioned in this conversation

they might be in the top 10 best Giant teams ever .....maybe

some of the best Giant teams ever unfortunately didn't win championships

The ones who are mentioning 07 & 11, clearly are much younger fans

[SweetZombieJesus]

The 2011 team by a country mile!
As great as the '86 and 90 teams were, they weren't the best team in the NFL the next year like the 2011 team was!
The 2011 team came the closest to repeating
The 2011 team was the only team in the modern Giants era to win the division and even make the playoffs the season after a SB championship.

I don't count the Sam Huff era because as great as those guys were in their time, the game was so different then, and those players don't compare to the athletes of today.

You're wrong in about 37 different ways. Just about everything you said is wrong.

The 1986 team had no good followup because 1987 was a strike year and there were replacement players playing for a good part of the season.

I assume you mean the 2012 team not the 2011 team... The 2011 team could not have repeated because they didn't make the playoffs in 2010 and they didn't make the playoffs in 2012. Since they didn't make the playoffs or win the division, what in blue blazes are you even talking about? Are you talking about the 2007 & 2008 teams?

The 2012 team was no where near as good as the 2008 team was.

[SweetZombieJesus]

The 86 team was great, but how can you say that they were better than the 2011 team when the 86 team didn't make the playoffs the next year?

The 2011 team didn't make the playoffs the next year either. Or are you watching imaginary Giants playoff games and not sharing what you are smoking?

[SweetZombieJesus]

The QB makes the team.

So the '84 Dolphins are the best team evar!!!!1!!

[Giantsfan241]

So the '84 Dolphins are the best team evar!!!!1!!

I said with sb's

[Broadway Blue]

Big Blue Wrecking Crew is all I got to say

[nhpgiantsfan]

I said with sb's

So are the 2000 Ravens the best Raven team ever because of Trent Dilfer?