Tuck, Osi, Chase, Webster, Snee, Diehl. Who should go?

[Dabluguy]

I say give Tuck another year. If he is lousy then buh bye.

[Mlerman17]

def not webster, snee, or tuck..osi is already gone...chase/diehl should go imo

[Cloud57]

in 2014 none of those guys will be here, that's for sure!

[Drez]

I dont get how people here are ok with webster at his cap hit. Its not like he was any better than anyone else we had last year and for all that money im moving on.

It was also only one bad year. I don't think we cut him unless it's part of a move to sign another CB. I don't think we do it before we have a replacement for him.

[Harooni]

everyone on the list shouldnt be safe. but even if all were cut i still dont think we would be rebuilding. most of them under performed anyway. and are near or over 30

[hungrrrry]

Justin Tuck
Osi Umenyiora
Chase Blackburn
Corey Webster
Chris Snee
David Diehl

Who needs to go, and who should stay?

I say keep Tuck for 1 more year and let him ride out his contract, hopefully giving all his effort. The rest I say replace.

I would rather keep Osi over Tuck honestly but Osi is a FA so he is going anyway...Snee is really the only one of this list that I would keep

[JJC7301]

I'd keep Chase as a backup because he's not expensive and he does bring some value and ALOT of heart.

I keep Web and Tuck one more year to see how they do.

I'd cut ties with the others.

[miked1958]

Diehl & Webster.. maybe bring them back for cheap

diehl for sure needs to go earning 7 Million a yr this season

[Sean Montemayor]

diehl for sure needs to go earning 7 Million a yr this season

+1

[bigblue58]

Justin Tuck
Osi Umenyiora
Chase Blackburn
Corey Webster
Chris Snee
David Diehl

Who needs to go, and who should stay?

I say keep Tuck for 1 more year and let him ride out his contract, hopefully giving all his effort. The rest I say replace.

You would think that the Giants would have learned their lesson with Blackburn. Give me a name of any other Giants LBer who came close to making as many plays consistently as Blackburn.