I would only have a problem with you if you came to the boards the day after the draft raging over us selecting a guy who Reese might like who doesnt fit your opinion. Like if we selected Chance or something.
The only way the fact that Maclin was gone is a bad argument, is if someone thought we should have moved up, which would have been crazy given the high rating Nicks had.
"Phil Simms is the greatest QB in Giants history" ........Mahatma Gandhi
But, I was just refering to the clear divide in opinions on these boards about him. People love him or people hate him. If he were the pick there would be a lot of positive posts and a lot of complaints too.