This is a very old article. I read it years ago.
Get well, get back #80
Believe it or not I disagree.
Originally Posted by B&RWarrior
Tiki was a great player but Eli is a QB and we won 2 SB's with him at the helm.
I definitely have to put Eli ahead of Tiki in the list of all time Giants.
Plus we won one of those the season after he retired which, like it or not, devalues Tiki a tad.
Excuse me while I get my winter jacket out, I beleive hell has just froze over.
Originally Posted by Morehead State