Nassib could make sense
Consider for the moment Eli's age and that at some point in time he is not going to be the quick healer that he has been. Consider also that the Giants might make the playoffs or go farther in the playoffs each year for the next five years. Presumably that would make us reasonably happy. Now consider as a result that the Giants will have a perennial late draft position.
In that scenario, what are the probabilities that the Giants could draft somebody better than Nassib?
Frankly that's the only way I can understand picking a QB this year.