“The Giants have suffered so many injuries for so many seasons that they are now difficult to both evaluate and predict.”
- Football Outsiders Almanac
Joe I do hope that if Eli ever went down he can win a SB for us, no doubt at all. But the infatuation some fans on here have for him is not warranted.
Taken in the 4th round by a team who doesn't need a starting QB, they needed a backup, they got one. I hope that if the time ever calls for it he can step in and play, but if he was good he would of been taken earlier. I understand why RB's got looked up and other skill positions you can find talent in the later rounds, but QB's get looked over constantly because it's not likely you'll win the big one without a great QB these days.
we gave up a 6th round pick for a highly rated prospect which we clearly rated highly as well. i really don't get these 'omg we don't need a QB' threads. eli is 32, not 25. carr sucks so bad we may as well have coughlin as the backup QB. this is a low risk high reward play with a very good chance of giving us a decent chance of winning if eli goes down anytime after this season.
You mean a guy drafted in the 4th round and was passed over by his own coach in favor of EJ Manuel isn't the next Joe Montana?