Romo is even less clutch than Rivers, but on paper and when you see him play he's better than Eli except when it counts the most. In quarters one through three Romo is, dare I say, elite.
You can make a legitimate argument for Stafford and Ryan being better than Rivers.
Vick...c'mon. Cutler gambles too much.
I like what I see out of Dalton. Haven't watched him enough and compared him to Rivers.
Rivers will have a good year this year with no real star at WR and an aging Gates. In terms of pure throwing ability he's better than Eli, fortunately for us it takes more than throwing ability to make a GREAT QB.