Nicks is one of the best receivers out there not named Johnson when he's healthy, not to mention one of my favorites. Randle could be real good but a Nicks type talent is hard to replace. Nicks' health will have a lot to say about his contract and how big it is and his Giant career.
Id rather have 80% talent 99% of the time then 99% talent 60% of the time.
"Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the mouth."