Obviously, he is not he only one who questioned Eli's decline. Even the Giants organization is doing the same thing. However, some fans here are really in denial and they see things with too many colored glasses and not objectively.
While I like Eli and I want him to do great, I questioned the same thing last year and the vitriol that came from some here was beyond imagination. There is nothing wrong with questioning the abilities of players as they get older no matter who the players are. The Giants organization should be looking for the eventual replacement of Eli and grab the opportunity if it presents itself. Perhaps that may be Nassib or another QB. As far as Nassib goes, unless Eli is really hurt, I am not sure we will see too much of him this year.
The Giants right now are a big question mark and Eli is not the only one who needs to be questioned. Others must also perform: from an inexperienced OC to JPP and the rest of the players. We really would not know until this season begins and see what Eli can do under the new OC and with new players. However, there is no denying this: So far Reese has done what he needed to do in FA and I expect him to do well in the draft. Beyond that, it is out of his control and if the Giants do not improve, then we have to look elsewhere for the cause.