I don't wany any yelling or insulting either way, keep things civil!

How come everyone is so against the Giants trading for Briggs? Now i don't think this deal is going to happen, but I would love to see it happen for say, this years 1st and 4th, or this years 1st and a pick next year. My reasoning for this is that the draft is always a gamble, and I would rather have a young, proven pro bowl linebacker in Briggs than an unproven player from the draft. I understand the team isn't a player away from being a super bowl contender, but it would certainly improve the defense. Thoughts?