Did Vernon Davis step out?

[dan1552]

I watched the replay , looked like he did.

[MikeIsaGiant]

Weird angle, IMO he did...

Did they show it any other way but on his left?

[Blue daddy]

It was real close but the ref was right on it . He had a better look at it then we did.

[nygsb42champs]

The replay did not give a great view. To hard to call.

[JMFP2]

The replay looked that way, but his heel didn't come down, so it was hard to confirm....close call, and since the ruling on the field was TD, no way were the refs going to overturn that one.</P>


Personally, I think he was out.</P>


Would be nice if the NFL upgraded their cameras.....the security camera at my local 7-Eleven has better resolution.</P>


</P>

[BigBlue1971]

on the replays his right foot angle seemed to touch the line.</P>


the ref said there was no clear evidence that he stepped out.</P>


i personally believe they didnt look at all angles of the replay. </P>

[bigblue4417]

I just thought it was funny how long it took Ed to explain it.

[paul007]

NO. Although his foot was turned and the the heel of his foot appeared over the white out of bounds, he was stepping on the front tip of his foot which was on the green in bounds. The heel of his foot was never in contact with the ground painted in white.Therefore it was too tough to overturn and the refs made the right call.

What i didn't understand was why the refs didn't call holding against the 49ers OL a few times when our DL was clearly held
or what i thought was clearly offsides by the 49er defense by Smith and he sacked Eli.

[Kruunch]

[quote user="dan1552"]I watched the replay , looked like he did.[/quote]

It looked like he did to me too but since it was questionable even on the replay, there wasn't enough to overturn the call.

I think they got the call and subsequent review right though.

[Ruttiger711]

Agree with there not being enough to overturn... but of course i think he was out... </P>


The clearest thing to see is man coverage on Davis w a safety is a bad idea and probably shouldnt do it again... uhh..</P>