The Debate has now changed

[JMFP2]

Is Eli the best QB in the NFL?</P>


Is Coughlin the best Coach?</P>


I'm not saying they are.....but I am saying it is now a valid debate.</P>

[miked1958]

Yep. They are now in the conversation

[GmenFan1980]

Best 4th Quarter Quarterback is Eli

1 of the best coaches In Coughlin

[MikeIsaGiant]

**** that debate, skeet skeeted all over the patriots

[giantfanatic]

I know one thing - Eli is the best quarterback in the class --- his two super bowl wins and his post season heroics are way way way more impressive than Big Ben's resume.

And the great thing is he ain't breaking down anytime soon.

[mrg3]

Wheres all the fire Coughlin and Reese So called fans when we were 7-7 Jak u there. Maybe we can get Cohwer next year

[ebick]

Best QB in Giants history? Hard to say no to that. I loved watching Simms (who *should* have won two also), I never saw Tittle, but at this point......Eli is the man and I truly believe he is just now hitting his stride and in his prime.....

[giantfanatic]

I loved Phil. but this guy is better.

Just my opinion, but it's not even close.
Records are made to be broken and Phil's will be smashed.

[giantsfan420]

w.o a doubt the best giants qb of all time and that really says a lot bc we've had amazing ones. it shouldnt be a slight at all to simms, he should feel proud of his career and what he did but really, as of tonight, its not even a debate in my mind.

in the league, i can honestly say there is no qb i'd take over eli. coughlin said it best "eli's always been my top 1 qb". in terms of stats, no eli's not the best. in terms of clutch ability and being able to will the team to victory, i'd say he's the best and in those areas its not even close.

brady will go down as one of the best EVER, and eli outplayed him in 2 super bowls.

for me, world champion means the best in the league. eli is the best qb in the nfl as a result of being a world champion.

my take on it.

coughlin also 2-0 vs BB one of the best coaches of all time, some say THE best coach of all time. again, he's a world champion. theres only one world champion head coach and thats coughlin. therefore, he is the best in the league.

[allentown PA]

[quote user="JMFP2"]

Is Eli the best QB in the NFL?</P>


Is Coughlin the best Coach?</P>


I'm not saying they are.....but I am saying it is now a valid debate.</P>[/quote]

my thoughts excatly..thats the new debate because honestly i dont know who u would rather have.