Is it fair to say that..........

[jomo]

Eli is already the greatest Giants quarterback ever?</P>


I believe he closed the deal with this playoff run and SB victory.</P>


Thoughts?</P>

[speedman]

Absolutely. I was convinced before this SB run.

[bansaw]

he's just coming into his prime too

[jomo]

[quote user="speedman"]Absolutely. I was convinced before this SB run.[/quote]Before this run, I thought he would be but now I believe he already is.

[TheEnigma]

At this point, he is. Now it's time to see how much he can distance himself from Simms and Title.

[gmen0820]

He has the stats, tangibles, intangibles and rings. There is no argument for the opposition, which would be Simms.


Or Danny Kanell. jk.

[jomo]

[quote user="gmen0820"]He has the stats, tangibles, intangibles and rings. There is no argument for the opposition, which would be Simms. Or Danny Kanell. jk.[/quote]You sure you don't mean Dave Brown? []

[nygsb42champs]

I think that with the 2nd Super Bowl he passed Phil Simms as the best. It is hard to compare becasue of the different era's they played in but I would go with Eli.

[bandwgn86]

[quote user="jomo"]

Eli is already the greatest Giants quarterback ever?</P>


I believe he closed the deal with this playoff run and SB victory.</P>


Thoughts?</P>[/quote]second still
Jesse Palmer
Eli
Phil
Lol.. I think he's moved into first even though it's hard to say that. Phil was the man, loved his fire.

[giantsfan420]

[quote user="gmen0820"]He has the stats, tangibles, intangibles and rings. There is no argument for the opposition, which would be Simms.


Or Danny Kanell. jk.[/quote]

this. hey man, i was curious as to how u felt about the SB and anything u noticed. u should make a thread bout it, i'd love to read your take on it