one thing for sure, JPP > OSI

[blueNorange]

the fact that jpp was lined up inside when osi came back was a joke. you can tell the difference , especially against the run with jpp starting.

[Antwuan]

JPP is a beast and he is very good against the run.

[Marvelousmik]

[quote user="blueNorange"]the fact that jpp was lined up inside when osi came back was a joke. you can tell the difference , especially against the run with jpp starting.[/quote]

dont get me wrong, i think jpp is better. but wit all due respect id like to see jpp go against jason peters, like osi did

[JMFP2]

Right now, there isn't a defensive end in the NFL that is more dangerous than JPP.

[TheEnigma]

[quote user="Marvelousmik"][quote user="blueNorange"]the fact that jpp was lined up inside when osi came back was a joke. you can tell the difference , especially against the run with jpp starting.[/quote]

dont get me wrong, i think jpp is better. but wit all due respect id like to see jpp go against jason peters, like osi did
[/quote]I think JPP would have a better chance against him. Peters is a pretty big dude for a LT but still has the feet for handling speed rushers. JPP has more strength at this point and using power against Peters might give better results.

[JMFP2]

[quote user="TheEnigma"][quote user="Marvelousmik"][quote user="blueNorange"]the fact that jpp was lined up inside when osi came back was a joke. you can tell the difference , especially against the run with jpp starting.[/quote]

dont get me wrong, i think jpp is better. but wit all due respect id like to see jpp go against jason peters, like osi did
[/quote]I think JPP would have a better chance against him. Peters is a pretty big dude for a LT but still has the feet for handling speed rushers. JPP has more strength at this point and using power against Peters might give better results.[/quote]</P>


</P>


I remember game 1....JPP beat Peters, rushed Vick....Vick managed to avoid the rush....JPP turned around, pursued Vick all the way down the field, and clobbered Vick.</P>


Meanwhile, Peters had already given up on the play.</P>

[Itlan]

It's not even JPP > Osi, it's JPP > Osi AND Tuck. When JPP & Osi were on the field, didn't they tally up something like 8 sacks in 3 games? When JPP was starting in place of Osi in the beginning of the year with Tuck, both were highly effective.

Then we go back to Osi/Tuck lineup and our pass rush falls apart. Now today, Osi is out and JPP is back in a starting role and the pass rush, at points, looked FEROCIOUS. He just does something to this d-line that neither of those two can do anymore. He plays inspired football!

[RagTime Blue]

I wouldn't have said this at the start of training camp, but we have GOT to trade Osi. Nothing against him, but as long as he's suited-up, he's taking snaps at RDE away from JPP (mostly because our coaches value seniority over talent).

[hungrrrry]

I really like Osi but I am not sure he has anything for the Giants...trade him and get what we can and let him finish up somewhere else...preferably in the AFC

[GIANTSACK]

Jpp ability to stay in th passing lane when hes not trying to create pressure is amazing. I never seen a DE go or get that many PD in a one game alone.. hes like playing better then our 3rd corner right now. Throw in the relentless motor and freak athletic player and we have our team a true baller who should never be on the bench. If we do the coaches need to get pimp smack