resigning manningham is a must

[nygfan0816]

we know manningham isnt the best receiver, but he is very good, he had a great season in 2010 and great run this postseason.

now i know we have a great 1-2 wit nicks and cruz, but nicks always has an injury and may miss a few games in a season, and now ballard tore his alc and so we have ?? about TE going into next season. if 1 of our WR goes down we're screwed. manningham is a great #3 receiver and can start if any1 were to go down.

idk bout u guys but nothing barden or jenigan has done for me to think they will do anything next year.

[Mod_C]

[quote user="nygfan0816"]we know manningham isnt the best receiver, but he is very good, he had a great season in 2010 and great run this postseason.

now i know we have a great 1-2 wit nicks and cruz, but nicks always has an injury and may miss a few games in a season, and now ballard tore his alc and so we have ?? about TE going into next season. if 1 of our WR goes down we're screwed. manningham is a great #3 receiver and can start if any1 were to go down.

idk bout u guys but nothing barden or jenigan has done for me to think they will do anything next year.[/quote]

I agree about Barden but Jernigan is a rookie and we need to see what he has to offer.

Manningham is not a must have, he's a nice to have.

[bLuereverie]

No it's not. Not at the expense of other positions which are far more deficient.

[perez201]

hed be nice to keep, but he will get more money somewhere else and i cant see manningham lowering his price range to resign with us

[nygfan0816]

[quote user="perez201"]hed be nice to keep, but he will get more money somewhere else and i cant see manningham lowering his price range to resign with us[/quote]

i thought about that but wit all the WR in free agency i think manningham may fall to us at a cheaper price

[bLuereverie]

[quote user="nygfan0816"][quote user="perez201"]hed be nice to keep, but he will get more money somewhere else and i cant see manningham lowering his price range to resign with us[/quote]

i thought about that but wit all the WR in free agency i think manningham may fall to us at a cheaper price[/quote]

Until some roster moves are made by FO, he can accept pennies and it still wouldn't be adequate.

[KidA]

[quote user="nygfan0816"]we know manningham isnt the best receiver, but he is very good, he had a great season in 2010 and great run this postseason.

now i know we have a great 1-2 wit nicks and cruz, but nicks always has an injury and may miss a few games in a season, and now ballard tore his alc and so we have ?? about TE going into next season. if 1 of our WR goes down we're screwed. manningham is a great #3 receiver and can start if any1 were to go down.

idk bout u guys but nothing barden or jenigan has done for me to think they will do anything next year.[/quote]

You forgot half of your argument:

What starter(s) do we let go in order to pay for Manningham?

[jomo]

I never heard of a player resigning. Plenty have re-signed. []

[n420p69]

It would be awesome but I have a feeling someone(Browns?) are going to throw him a ton of money out of our range for a 3rd receiver.

[NYBlue10]

I'm fully confident that not re-signing Mario will come back to bite the team next season.